Signs Point to Yes
Skip to: For departments using this technology
A detective runs a bank-camera image through facial recognition, gets a match, and swears out a warrant saying he used “investigative tools” and the photos matched. He doesn’t tell the judge the match came from software, or that his department’s own policy says a facial-recognition result doesn’t establish probable cause without further investigation.
That’s what Alain Vizcay Osorio alleges, and a federal judge just declined to throw out his Section 1983 claims in an opinion that explains qualified immunity with a Magic 8 Ball. Osorio v. Kilmer, 2026 WL 3390238 (E.D. Ky. Nov. 9, 2026).
It combines two of my favorite things to read about: the Fourth Amendment and AI.
This was a ruling on a motion for judgment on the pleadings, so the court accepted Osorio’s factual allegations as true and said more than once that discovery might change the picture.
What Osorio alleges
Someone tried to cash a suspected fraudulent check at a Kentucky bank using a fake Texas driver’s license. The teller refused, but the security camera got a clear look at the person’s face. Florence police detective Ryan Kilmer ran the image through facial recognition, which connected it to a booking photo of Osorio and a Facebook profile under a different name. Osorio says Kilmer treated the software’s answer as the end of the inquiry.
The criminal complaint said Kilmer had used “investigative tools” to find the booking photo, compared it with the footage, and found that they matched. Osorio says they didn’t, and the court described differences in head shape, haircut, facial features, and complexion. Osorio, a Nebraska resident, was arrested in Florida, extradited to Kentucky, and spent more than two weeks in jail before getting out on bond. The indictment was dismissed with prejudice after he showed he’d been working in Nebraska when the check was presented. Id. at *1–2.
The policy said the right thing
What caught my attention was that the department already had a policy on this. It said facial recognition was “advisory” and did not “establish probable cause without further investigation.” Id. at *2.
That’s the language you’d hope to see in a facial-recognition policy. Here it helped the plaintiff. The court reasoned that the policy supported an inference that Kilmer knew the match wasn’t enough, relied on it anyway, and then described his work in a way that was intentionally or recklessly misleading. Id. at *5.
That isn’t the same as saying a policy violation is a constitutional violation. I wrote about that distinction in Henderson v. Village of New Holland, where an incomplete inventory didn’t make the search unconstitutional. Osorio’s claim is about the warrant. The policy mattered because it supported an inference that the detective understood the limits of the tool he was using.
Kilmer also argued that the warrant still had probable cause without the challenged statements. The court disagreed: what was left showed that someone committed a crime, not that Osorio was that someone. Osorio, 2026 WL 3390238, at *5. That’s an old warrant problem with new technology. A software match doesn’t explain away a face that looks different, and “investigative tools” doesn’t tell the reviewing judge that the identification rested entirely on an uncorroborated AI result.
The Magic 8 Ball
On qualified immunity, Kilmer argued that no case had held that relying exclusively on AI facial recognition violates the Fourth Amendment. The court said Osorio didn’t need a case involving that same technology. On his allegations, Sixth Circuit cases on unreliable evidence and recklessly false statements in warrant affidavits were enough. Id. at *7–8.
Then the court imagined a detective who asks a Magic 8 Ball whether a passing pedestrian is the suspect, gets an affirmative answer, and obtains a warrant based on his use of “investigative tools.” When he’s sued, he argues that no prior case specifically prohibited using a Magic 8 Ball that way.
That illustrates the rare “obvious case” exception to the usual demand for closely analogous precedent, which the court offered as an additional basis for its decision. The court allowed that facial recognition is likely more reliable than a Magic 8 Ball. But unquestioned reliance on it, without corroboration and despite the alleged differences in appearance, didn’t become reasonable just because no earlier opinion described those exact facts. Id. at *8.
For departments using this technology
Find out what officers actually do when the system returns a possible match. If the policy calls for further investigation, what does that look like in practice, and could someone reviewing the file tell it happened? Supervisors who review warrant applications should also know how an identification was made, especially when the wording suggests more independent verification than actually occurred.
There was no ruling on municipal liability, and Kilmer may still establish qualified immunity after discovery. Id. at *9. But the court’s opening line is worth repeating: “The Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution does not allow a detective to delegate to AI the task of assessing probable cause.” Id. at *1.